A recent debate over the environmental impacts of farmed seafood has brought renewed attention to the role of wild-caught fish in aquaculture feed. Following an investigation published in The New York Times alleging that fish farming contributes to overfishing, fisheries scientist Emily De Sousa has published a detailed response examining what the reporting gets right—and where it overlooks important developments in modern aquaculture.
In her article, What The New York Times Got Right (and Wrong) About Farmed Fish, De Sousa explains that treating all farmed seafood as environmentally identical overlooks substantial differences among species, production systems, and feed requirements.
For trout farmers, the discussion surrounding feed efficiency and responsible sourcing is particularly relevant. Fishmeal and fish oil remain valuable ingredients in many aquaculture diets because of their nutritional properties, but feed formulations have changed considerably over the past several decades. Research and innovation have helped reduce dependence on marine ingredients while maintaining the nutritional quality and performance required for healthy fish growth.
Modern aquaculture feeds increasingly incorporate alternative ingredients, including plant proteins and oils, algae-derived omega-3 fatty acids, insect proteins, and emerging microbial proteins. Fish-processing byproducts are also playing a larger role in feed production, allowing valuable nutrients from seafood processing to be recovered and reused.
According to De Sousa, processing byproducts accounted for approximately 34% of global fishmeal production and 54% of fish oil production in 2024. These improvements represent meaningful progress toward more efficient use of marine resources.
The broader production figures also illustrate aquaculture’s growing importance in global seafood supply. Global aquaculture produced approximately 103 million metric tons of aquatic animals in 2024, accounting for 53% of total production. Wild capture fisheries, by comparison, have remained relatively stable for approximately 30 years. Aquaculture has therefore supplied nearly all of the growth in global seafood production during that period.
The article does not dismiss legitimate concerns about seafood supply chains. Forced labor, inadequate oversight, and irresponsible sourcing practices must be addressed wherever they occur. De Sousa points to improved certification programs, stronger import enforcement, and more comprehensive social responsibility assessments as examples of efforts to improve accountability.
For the U.S. trout industry, the discussion reinforces the importance of continued research, feed innovation, fish health management, and responsible resource utilization. Aquaculture is not a single production method, and the sustainability of farmed seafood cannot be evaluated through generalized assumptions about feed ingredients or isolated examples of poor practices.
As demand for nutritious seafood continues, domestic trout producers have an important role in contributing to a reliable food supply while advancing efficient and responsible production practices.
Read the full analysis: What The New York Times Got Right (and Wrong) About Farmed Fish